Ask any nursery owner or manager what keeps them up at night, and staffing will come up before almost anything else. Recruitment. Retention. The dread of another resignation letter landing on the desk in September, just as the new intake settles in.
It’s easy to treat these as separate problems. A recruitment issue here, a retention issue there, a difficult conversation you keep putting off. But pull on any of these threads for long enough and they usually lead back to the same place: culture.
Toxic culture rarely arrives all at once. It builds slowly, through a hire that wasn’t quite right, a difficult conversation that got avoided, a process that was never quite clear enough. By the time it’s visible, it’s already shaping how your team feels about coming to work, and how long they stay.
The early warning signs
Most early years leaders don’t set out to build a toxic culture. It creeps in through small, everyday things that feel manageable in isolation: a bit of gossip, a clique forming among senior staff, a member of the team who’s checked out but still turning up. On their own, none of these feel like a crisis. Together, they add up to an environment where good people quietly start looking elsewhere.
The settings that get ahead of this aren’t the ones with perfect teams. They’re the ones who notice the early signs and act before culture becomes the default explanation for every resignation.
Why recruitment is where it actually starts
It’s tempting to think of culture as something you manage after people join. In reality, the foundation is laid at the point of hire. Every person you bring into a setting either reinforces the culture you want or chips away at it.
This is where safe, structured recruitment practices matter, not just for safeguarding reasons, but because they force a level of intentionality that protects the team you’re building. Hiring under pressure, just to fill a rota gap, is one of the most common ways toxic culture takes root. It rarely feels like the wrong decision at the time. It usually only becomes clear six months later.
Retention is a culture problem before it’s a pay problem
When staff leave, it’s easy to point to pay or hours as the reason. Sometimes that’s true. But often, people don’t leave jobs, they leave environments where they don’t feel valued, supported, or heard.
Retention improves when staff can see a clear path, know what’s expected of them, and trust that difficult situations will be handled fairly. That means having the confidence to have hard conversations early, rather than letting frustration build on both sides until someone hands in their notice.
Building something better
None of this is about perfection. Every setting has difficult moments, mismatched hires, and awkward conversations that need to happen. What separates a healthy culture from a toxic one is whether leaders have the tools, confidence, and processes to deal with these moments before they compound.
That’s exactly what we’ll be unpacking in our upcoming webinar.
Toxic Culture Starts Somewhere: Early Years Recruitment & Staff Retention
Friday, 24 July 2026, 10:00 to 11:00 AM BST
Join us for a practical, honest look at the challenges facing early years leaders today, from recruitment and retention to managing difficult workplace cultures and supporting high-performing teams.
Our expert HR consultant will share practical advice, real-world examples, and actionable strategies to help you create a positive working environment that supports both your staff and the children in your care.
What we’ll cover:
- Recognising the early signs of a toxic workplace culture
- Why recruitment is the foundation of a healthy nursery culture
- Safe recruitment practices that help you hire the right people
- Practical strategies to improve staff retention and engagement
- Supporting performance while managing difficult conversations confidently
- Creating clear processes that protect your team and your setting
- Building a culture where staff feel valued, supported and motivated
Whether you’re an owner, manager, deputy manager or HR professional, you’ll leave with ideas you can put into practice immediately.
